Wildlife Photography and Writings of Harry Morse

Muzzleloader Hunting a Challenge 

Break out the buckskins and the coon-skin cap and take the muzzleloader down from the mantle. Check the "possible pouch" for powder horn, percussion caps, round balls and patches. Get ready to stalk through the woods with the ghosts of Davy Crockett and Daniel Boone.

Thanksgiving season is here, and it is time to hunt deer and elk with traditional muzzleloaders. A time to return to our pilgrim roots and pioneer heritage. Time to enjoy and endure pleasures and frustrations of primitive weapon hunting.

From Payette to Preston muzzleloaders are checking the hunting regulations and circling their favorite traditional muzzleloader hunts. Some of these hunts are open to anyone with a license and a deer or elk tag. Other highly prized hunts required applications to be mailed in May and a lottery type draw to determine the winners of the coveted permits.

"Traditional muzzleloader hunts are a way to offer an excellent hunting experience and opportunity for a late deer or elk hunt," says Brad Compton, of the Idaho Department of Fish and Game. "Late traditional muzzleloader hunts out of Payette, Ashton and Grace, Idaho give hunters the chance to see and hunt some really fine mule deer bucks."

What the heck is traditional muzzle-loading? Can any hunter master the art of traditional muzzleloading?

According to Pocatello gunsmith David Crockett, just about anyone with the interest and stick-to-it-tiveness can learn the basics of traditional muzzle-loading.

Modern-day man tinkered and engineered improvements to muzzle-loading rifles. Traditional muzzleloader seasons eliminate most of these improvements, from scopes to specialized powder packets and sealed ignition systems. Space-age improvements are prohibited for traditional muzzleloader hunts.

Modern-day rifles chamber shells are assembled to rigorous safety specifications. You pull the trigger, and the bullet hurdles through the barrel at speeds exceeding 3,000 feet per second. No problem. Just put another shell in and shoot again with precise accuracy.

Not so with traditional muzzle-loading. The hunter builds the load on the spot by measuring the powder and pouring it into the barrel, wrapping a patch of cloth under a round lead ball and pounding it down the barrel of the gun with a long wooden stick. It's kind of like building a pipe bomb.

The hunter must place a percussion or musket cap over a striking hole or nipple for the muzzleloader's hammer to strike and explode. This sends a miniature ball of fire to the powder loaded in the barrel. If all goes well, the powder ignites, sending the round ball down the barrel at about 1,500 feet per second. Sounds easy?


Long-time friend and traditional muzzleloader Bill Gillespie tells of hunting elk and missing a fine bull on the first shot. Distracted by the giant bull elk tearing up a tree in front of him, he frantically reloaded but forgot one step. Putting the powder in. Oops.

After crawling through cactus on my hands and knees sneaking up on a pronghorn antelope, I cocked the hammer, sighted, pulled the trigger and the percussion cap popped, but the powder didn't ignite. The antelope vanished.

With a giant buck in his sights last year, a veteran hunter pulled the trigger on a buck of a lifetime near Grace. The percussion cap did not ignite. Off went the deer.

How did those pilgrims put food on the table? The list of things that can and do go wrong for traditional muzzleloaders is as long as the human experience with muzzleloaders. Nothing is a sure thing with traditional muzzleloaders. That is the fun of it. Break out the coon-skin hat!


Grace muzzleloader hunt

Snow conditions are favorable for the controlled traditional muzzleloader hunt out of Grace. Lucky hunters should see more deer than last year due to snow conditions.

Considered one of the best mule deer opportunities in the state, it became so popular that biologists limited hunter numbers at 200 and switched it to traditional muzzle-loading equipment to limit the harvest of mature bucks.

Just three years ago as an unlimited controlled hunt, the numbers of permit hunters soared to a record 800.

Success over the past three years using in-line muzzleloaders averaged 35 to 40 percent on bucks on this hunt. Biologists decided to take the conservative path by reducing hunter numbers and switching to traditional muzzle-loading equipment to limit harvest. The hunt was changed from an either sex hunt to bucks only this year. From 1982-2002 muzzle-loading success state-wide was 20 percent on deer.

Success with traditional muzzleloaders is consistently less than with the new generation of improved muzzleloaders.

"We will see how these restrictions work and how hunters do," said Corey Class, regional wildlife biologist for IDFG. "Can we keep more opportunity by reducing technology rather than cutting down on permits?"

Traditional muzzleloaders must use patch and ball, percussion or musket cap, black powder, Pyrodex, or synthetic black powder and have an exposed hammer that pivots. No telescopic sights are allowed. These restrictions eliminate many modern muzzleloaders with in-line ignition systems, specialized powder pellets, bullet casings and scopes.

Travel restrictions for ATVs are also in place. This will limit hunter mobility over the snow. In units with new travel restrictions, hunter success declines.

Colorado muzzleloader success was 29 percent last year on bucks with similar traditional muzzle-loading restrictions, without travel restrictions, according to big game manager John Ellensburg with Colorado Fish and Game.

 

    PO Box 1707    ▪    Pocatello, Idaho  83204   ▪    208.220.1169    ▪    Email Me

Home   ▪  Photography   ▪  Wildlife Stories   ▪  About Me   ▪  Hire Me!   ▪  Seminars   ▪  Resources  ▪  Search

All photos and articles are property of Harry Morse © 2005